Soft robots can't always compete with the hard. Their rigid brethren dominate assembly lines, perform backflips, dance to Bruno Mars' 'Uptown Funk', fly, dive, and walk through volcanoes.
But each year, soft robots gain new abilities. They've learned to jump, squirm, and grip. And, unlike hard robots, they can handle tomatoes without bruising the fruit, resurface unscathed after being run over by a car, and journey through radiation, disaster zones, and outer-space with few scars. For people and animals, they have a 'co-operative function': a soft touch.
Recently, researchers in the lab of George M Whitesides, the Woodford L and Ann A Flowers University Professor, have invented soft replacements for the last hard parts required to build a robot.
Replicates the same capabilities of an electronic computer
Instead of electricity and wires, pressurised air expands and contracts rubber inflatables to create movement, soft valves take over for the hard, and soft digital logic replicates the same capabilities of an electronic computer.
Now, postdoctoral scholar Daniel J Preston's latest soft invention gives these robots new, complex movements. As first author on a study published in 'Science Robotics', he introduces the first soft ring oscillator, which gives soft robots the ability to roll, undulate, sort, meter liquids, and swallow.
"It's another tool in the toolkit to make these smart, soft robots without any electronics, and without any hard valves," says Preston.
Until now, ring oscillators were made with electronic transistors or microfluidics. Electronics always require hard components. Most microfluidics do, too.
Many use glass for their pressurised water or air systems and require thin channels that can only handle very low flow rates, limiting operation speeds.
Tiny microfluidic systems might achieve higher frequencies than Preston's macroscale pneumatic ring oscillator, but his team already has blueprints to tweak their soft system to achieve greater speeds, if needed.
Soft ring oscillator relies on inverters
The soft ring oscillator - like all ring oscillators - relies on inverters ('NOT' digital logic gates). Preston's inverters, for example, manipulate the air pressure in his robot's rubber tubes: If the input is high pressure, the output will be low pressure and vice versa.
When three, or any odd number, of gates are connected in a ring, one gate's shift triggers the next, which triggers the next, and on and on.
"The cool response that you get when you combine an odd number of these inverters in a loop is an instability that travels around the loop," says Preston. Like a slinky that collapses in order to spring down a flight of stairs, one movement sparks the next, creating a constant pace without the need for another push.
To test what the soft ring oscillator could do, Preston and his team created five soft robot prototypes. Each uses a single, constant source of air pressure to run three pneumatic actuators (the inverters).
One prototype nudges a ball around a ring. Another undulates a stage to keep beads of two different sizes rolling against the edge. Eventually, all the smaller beads fall through a hole in the side of the stage. They sort themselves out.
"The ring oscillator is really good for things like rolling motions," says Preston. Rolling requires co-ordination of several actions in time. A single input and output will not suffice.
For example, to get their hexagonal foam robot to roll forward, the ring oscillator helps inflate a balloon behind the robot and deflate one in front at the exact same time. The co-ordinated push-and-release shifts the hexagon forward again and again as the balloons inflate and deflate in perfect sync.
Yet another prototype provides a more tangible purpose. A textile-based sleeve, wrapped around the lower leg and secured with Velcro, exerts co-ordinated pressure, 'pumping' fluid up the leg.
'Pumping' motion improves symptoms of lymphedema
According to recent studies, this 'pumping' motion improves symptoms of lymphedema and chronic venous disease better than simple compression. The device could also help nurses, waiters, and police officers prevent deep vein thrombosis, a result of working long shifts on tired feet.
Before they start clinical trials for their sleeve, the team wants to gauge interest. If enough people crave a softer, less expensive way to alleviate and prevent symptoms, the product might just find a big enough market to merit further research.
The low cost of Preston's materials - rubber-like silicone elastomers - make them ideal for more than just inexpensive homecare. Biocompatible, disposable, gentle, and sterile versions could be used for lab experiments, drug delivery, or even medical devices inside the body like this sleeve that helps the heart beat.
Preston's final prototype can sort three different colored liquids based on a predetermined sequence and time, a tool that could prove useful for chemists.
Though all of Preston's prototypes are made with only soft materials, they're not yet untethered: All rely on a constant source of pressurised air. Yet Preston and his colleagues have a few solutions for this, too.
For the leg sleeve, patients could provide their own air with a hand-held pump like those used to take blood pressure. And soft robots in the trenches could use mobile carbon dioxide cartridges, strapped on like a backpack, or gas-generating chemical reactions to set the bot in motion.
But Preston expects his new tool to achieve far more than the applications demonstrated in his five prototypes. Since the paper explains how to replicate and customize the design, he hopes other labs will find even more uses.
"People can use the soft ring oscillator for a lot of different applications in soft robotics, some of which we may not have even thought of or envisioned yet."